Design (6.4) — The yellow horned toad shooting a .30 caliber machine gun while perched on a cloud is a little creative, but not overly so. Simple concept, decently executed for the era.
Story (6.0) — The tee just represents the school — nothing too special. It shows the wearer trained at what's now Nellis Air Force Base, but that's about the extent of it.
Signature (9.3) — Being the first t-shirt ever captured in mass media is a massive legacy that's hard to top. The sheer number of replicas made over the decades is proof of how much influence this one design has had.
Quality (3.8) — The original is pretty dirty and worn out, likely from actual training use. It earns some points back since it was made by American Athletic Co., a real manufacturer, rather than something slapped together.
Value (9.1) — Given it sold for over $1,000 at auction and spawned a whole genre of reproductions, the value here is exceptional relative to what it originally was — a basic military tee. This original 1942 Las Vegas Gunnery School T-Shirt sold for $1,009 on August 23rd, 2015